I think he is decent going forward and works okay with the wingers, he has a great free kick in him which is a bonus. However i don't rate him as a defensive player at all, it doesn't help that he is on the same side with Cahill who is okay but mistake prone at times. I also stated that i don't think we will sign a new left wing back this season, we had to get cover for him because he can be crap for months and not get dropped. Overall he doesn't shine going forward of backwards, he is an above average player who has moments of brilliance, but overall we should look for a long term replacement.