It’s not at all the extreme. Are they capable of a good performance? Yes, but I’d say that for most the defenders in the PL. Gomez has been absolute shite for ages now, with a couple of non shit performances sprinkled in. Not good enough for us, yet he’s only 25/26 and has not longed signed a new contract so he’s not going anywhere.
Matip out of contract in the summer, see what happens there. If he goes then we maybe will finally bring in a top CB, because neither Virgil or Konate should be nailed on either. Virgil isn’t the player he was and has past 30 and Konate blows hot and cold.