Danny Posted May 17, 2017 Share Posted May 17, 2017 I started this topic on TFF but obviously we're not there anymore. I'll be trying to update this so we have a comprehensive list of English academies as well as foreign. The below is copy and pasted. There are no rules to the ranking currently, if anyone wants to try and create some then go ahead. Points per tier system would be good based on appearances/silverware/career stats. The only rule is you cannot include retired players. Players bought from other academies at 16 will be marked as questionable. Players playing at a lower level will be separated. Once we have a good list we can start the group wranking. Southampton: Gareth Bale Theo Walcott Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain Luke Shaw Adam Lallana James Ward-Prowse Matt Targett Calum Chambers Leeds Scum: Aaron Lennon Paul Robinson Jonathan Woodgate Fabian Delph Lewis Cook Sam Byram Tom Cairney Scott Carson Luke Garbutt Man Utd: Marcus Rashford Jesse Lingard Cameron Borthwick-Jackson Danny Drinkwater Darren Fletcher Danny Welbeck Ryan Shawcross Tom Heaton Craig Cathcart Fraizer Campbell Alex Bruce Robbie Brady?? Jonny Evans?? Darron Gibson?? John O'Shea?? Joshua King?? Adnan Januzaj?? James Chester Cory Evans?? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SirBalon Posted May 17, 2017 Share Posted May 17, 2017 FC BARCELONA Jordi Masip (FC Barcelona) Gerard Piqué (FC Barcelona) Sergio Busquets (FC Barcelona) Sergi Roberto (FC Barcelona) Andrés Iniesta (FC Barcleona) Lionel Messi (FC Barcelona) Carles Aleña (FC Barcelona) Jordi Alba (FC Barcelona) Denis Suárez (FC Barcelona) Rafinha (FC Barcelona) Victor Valdés (Middlesbrough) Marc Muniesa (Stoke City) Cesc Fàbregas (Chelsea FC) Pedro (Chelsea FC) Héctor Bellerín (Arsenal FC) Jon Toral (Arsenal FC "loan Glasgow Rangers") Oriol Romeu (Southampton) Adama Traoré (Middlesbrough) Damià Abella (Middlesbrough) Marc Bartra (Borussia Dortmund) Bojan Krkić (Stoke City "loan FSV Mainz 05") Thiago Alcántara (Bayern Munich) Thiago Motta (Paris Saint-Germain) Munir (Valencia CF) Martín Montoya (Valencia CF) Pepe Reina (SSC Napoli) Cristian Tello (Fiorentina) Mauro Icardi (Internazionale) Gerard Deulofeu (AC Milan) Iago Falqué (Torino) Alex Grimaldo (SL Benfica) Rubén Rochina (FC Rubin Kazan) Víctor Vázquez (Toronto FC) Sandro Ramírez (Málaga CF) Andreu Fontàs (Celta Vigo) Carles Planas (Celta Vigo) Sergi Gómez (Celta Vigo) Antonio Sanabria (Real Betis) Fernando Navarro (Deportivo La Coruña) Sergi Samper (Granada CF "loan") Jordi Gómez (Rayo Vallecano) Roberto Trashorras (Rayo Vallecano) Joan Verdú (Levante UD) Gai Assulin (Sabadell) That's all I can think about right now and I'll update it as I think of more. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Spike Posted May 17, 2017 Share Posted May 17, 2017 What about players that spent time at more than one academy? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Danny Posted May 17, 2017 Author Share Posted May 17, 2017 1 hour ago, Spike said: What about players that spent time at more than one academy? Depends on the timing really, you could never class Raheem Sterling as a Liverpool academy product for example. Same with Fabregas and Arsenal. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SirBalon Posted May 17, 2017 Share Posted May 17, 2017 7 minutes ago, Danny said: Depends on the timing really, you could never class Raheem Sterling as a Liverpool academy product for example. Same with Fabregas and Arsenal. Not for me... There is a reason those players got snapped up from other academies. Spike's point does have to be taken into consideration because there have been players that have jumped around academies quite a bit and there are a few even in the Barça list as there are for example in what's considered to be players from "La Fábrica" which is Real's academy nickname. This happens a lot in Spain between each other but the important academies are the ones that provide what turns out to be the most important results for these players. Even Ajax's academy is accused of that because they capture players from other academies and they either finish of the job or add the most important part because they're one of the best academies around. Take for example River Plate's academy in Argentina or Rosario Central... They're the best, but they canvas everyone else's for the raw talent and then turn it into something real. Trust me, Cesc (although extremely appreciative of what Arsenal provided as will Bellerín be too), will hold themselves as products of La Masia. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted May 17, 2017 Share Posted May 17, 2017 UNIVERSITARIO Raul Ruidiaz Edison Flores Andy Polo Juan Manuel Vargas Raul Fernandez Percy Rojas Juan Carlos Oblitas Roberto Chale Jose Luis Carranza Raul Ruidiaz now is at Monarcas. Top goalscorer in the overall league. Edison Flores at AaB Alborg, Andy Polo at Monarcas as well. Juan Manuel Vargas is back at Universitario but he's been one of the best Peruvian players in the century. He played for Fiorentina as his most reputable club. Raul Fernandez is also back at Universitario. Played for Nice in Europe and FC Dallas in the MLS, named for an MLS all star in 2013. The best player we've ever had was Hector Chumpitaz. He started at Deportivo Municipal but he's a legend with us. Surely you've heard of him @SirBalon ? ALIANZA LIMA Claudio Pizarro Paolo Guerrero Jefferson Farfan Yordy Reyna Teofilo Cubillas Jose Velasquez Wildar Saenz Claudio Pizarro and Jefferson Farfan made their professional debuts for Alianza but technically they played for other clubs prior. Pizarro at Academia Cantolao and Farfan at Deportivo Municipal. Paolo Guerrero started in Germany but he's always been at Alianza prior. Teofilo Cubillas on the other hand, is the best Peruvian player to ever play the game and one of the best players ever. SPORTING CRISTAL Julio Cesar Uribe Yoshimar Yotun Flavio Maestri Nolberto Solano Alberto Rodriguez Roberto Palacios Andres Mendoza Leao Butron This is probably the best of the 3. I believe on this forum Solano needs no introduction. Alberto Rodriguez is the best Peruvian CB in this century. Yoshimar Yotun is currently a key player in the current side. Flavio Maestri the "chile slayer" was a canny goalscorer who did well for us in the 1998 qualifiers. Roberto Palacios never played in Europe but he was the best Peruvian player in his time. Andres Mendoza has just been recently named a Club Brugge legend. Julio Cesar Uribe while eccentric, was a very good player. Lastly Leao Butron was a quality keeper in his time. One of the best since Quiroga. Others USMP Pedro Gallese Christian Cueva Aldo Corzo Juan Diego Gutierrez Sport Boys Alexander Callens Club Deportivo Zuñiga Renzo Sheput Andy Pando Edgar Villamarin Sydney Faiffer Cantolao Claudio Pizarro Carlos Zambrano Alexander Succar Deportivo Municipal Jefferson Farfan Hugo Sotil Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SirBalon Posted May 17, 2017 Share Posted May 17, 2017 10 minutes ago, LaSambadeStGermain said: Juan Manuel Vargas is back at Universitario but he's been one of the best Peruvian players in the century He did have a decent time at Fiore, but wasn't very good at Real Betis unfortunately. 11 minutes ago, LaSambadeStGermain said: The best player we've ever had was Hector Chumpitaz. He started at Deportivo Municipal but he's a legend with us. Surely you've heard of him @SirBalon ? He's definitely not in action anymore! Yep, I know of him in terms of what I've been told... One of those gifted players never to venture out like so many others back in the day. But why should they have done because back then most Latin American countries were economically rich (Venezuela being a perfect example) and the leagues were tremendous. But I know only what I've been told as with many other Latin American players of the past. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted May 17, 2017 Share Posted May 17, 2017 Just now, SirBalon said: He did have a decent time at Fiore, but wasn't very good at Real Betis unfortunately. He's definitely not in action anymore! Yep, I know of him in terms of what I've been told... One of those gifted players never to venture out like so many others back in the day. But why should they have done because back then most Latin American countries were economically rich (Venezuela being a perfect example) and the leagues were tremendous. But I know only what I've been told as with many other Latin American players of the past. About Vargas, at Betis he was pretty much past it by then. Still had some qualities as he showed in the 2015 Copa America but overall he was way past his prime. He was a player who completely tore apart any full backs in his way. He started off really well at Fiore but got worse over time although still decent. And don't even get me started on his time at Colon or for the NT. Superb player. Funnily enough back in November I wrote an article predicting that he would go back to Universitario. My finest prediction to date. Chumpitaz was "el capitan de America" up there in the books with Elias Figueroa and Pasarella. One of the best South American CB's of all time in Peru's golden generation. That was arguably the best non Argentina-Brazil-Uruguay South American side of all time. Teofilo Cubillas, Hector Chumpitaz, Percy Rojas, Hugo Sotil, Roberto Chale, Later on that decade came Ramon Quiroga, Juan Carlos Oblitas, Cesar Cueto and Julio Cesar Uribe. Of course, they won the Copa America in 1975. We've been totally useless at world level since 1985 but we've had decent generations since. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Storts Posted May 17, 2017 Share Posted May 17, 2017 Tottenham Harry Kane (Tottenham) Ryan Mason (Hull) Jake Livermore (West Brom) Harry Winks (Tottenham) Andros Townsend (Crystal Palace) Tom Carroll (Swansea) Peter Crouch (Stoke) Dean Marney (Burnley) Adam Smith (Bournemouth) Charlie Daniels (Bournemouth) David Button (Fulham) Ryan Fredericks (Fulham) Alex Pritchard (Norwich) Dominic Ball (Rotherham) Milos Veljkovic (Werder Bremen) Yuri Berchiche (Real Sociedad) Only down Prem/Championship players and a couple I can think of abroad. Probably missing a few and there's loads more in the lower leagues, but we're pretty good at producing football league players. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Smiley Culture Posted May 17, 2017 Share Posted May 17, 2017 Loads of players are taken from smaller clubs and the smaller club gets shit on as they don't get anywhere near what they believe they should for these kids. Kaylen Hinds (Arsenal), Kaziah Sterling (Spurs), Jay Beckford (Arsenal) and a few others have been at Orient at one time and have been poached by bigger clubs for peanuts. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
HK85 Posted May 17, 2017 Share Posted May 17, 2017 4 hours ago, Cannabis said: Everton: Wayne Rooney Ross Barkley Tom Davies Leon Osman (hasn't announced retirement) Jack Rodwell James Vaughan Victor Anichebe Me To add to these; Matthew Pennington - Everton Jonjoe Kenny - Everton Tyias Browning - Everton Kieran Dowell - Everton Adam Forshaw - Boro Eunan O'Kane - Leeds Jake Bidwell - QPR Ryan Ledson - Oxford John Lundstrum - Oxford Danny Fox - Forest Hope Akpan - Blackburn Only added ones still here who have made their debut already. I'm sure I've missed someone out as well. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SirBalon Posted May 17, 2017 Share Posted May 17, 2017 11 minutes ago, Smiley Culture said: Loads of players are taken from smaller clubs and the smaller club gets shit on as they don't get anywhere near what they believe they should for these kids. Kaylen Hinds (Arsenal), Kaziah Sterling (Spurs), Jay Beckford (Arsenal) and a few others have been at Orient at one time and have been poached by bigger clubs for peanuts. Similar to Harry Kane Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
HK85 Posted May 17, 2017 Share Posted May 17, 2017 1 minute ago, Cannabis said: Kieran Agard - Rotherham? Didn't know the cut off point on players like this, he was brought in from Arsenal. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.