Who's the best goalkeeper in the world?

[SirBalon]

There are some keepers that have been performing at the highest of levels for quite some time now like

• David de Gea (Spain / Manchester United)
• Jan Oblak (Slovakia / Atlético Madrid)
• Manuel Neuer (Germany / Bayern Munich)
• Marc-André ter Stegen (Germany / FC Barcelona
• Hugo Lloris (France / Tottenham Hotspur)
• Keylor Navas (Costa Rica / Real Madrid CF)
• Thibaut Courtois (Belgium / Real Madrid CF)
• Gianluigi Buffon (Italy / Paris Saint-Germain)
• Alisson Becker (Brazil / Liverpool)

Even young keepers that are pretenders to the throne like...

• Gianluigi Donnarumma (Italy / AC Milan)
• Alban Lafont (France / ACF Fiorentina)
• Kepa Arrizabalaga (Spain / Chelsea)
• Oscar Linnér (Sweden / AIK Fotboll)
• Mile Svilar (Belgium / SL Benfica)

We saw the error made by Joachim Löw in his selection and first team choice for the World Cup after Neuer had suffered a long term injury and was pushed right back into defend Germany's goalposts for their adventure in Russia...  Ter Stegen had been phenomenal not just last season but for at least three years beforehand and always getting better.

Who for you is the best, what's your top three and who do you see being the next best keeper in years to come?

[SirBalon]

1 minute ago, Cannabis said:

When fit? Neuer, easily.

Lloris, Navas, Courtois and Alisson shouldn't even be discussed in this topic.

Is that because he's Costa Rican??? 

[Beelzebub]

If we go by class is permanent and form is temporary than Neuer. 

But if by right now you really mean RIGHT NOW ! than Ter Stegen

[SirBalon]

Neuer is indeed class but we always have to leave a margin open for betterment, for natural talent and evolution.  Marc-André ter Stegen covers all of these categories and more.  Anyone that follows Barcelona will know what he has achieved on an individual argument and also taking into account how Barcelona play the game which has always meant that a keeper is more open to being tested.  All this without even going into his football technical ability with the ball at his feet because he is as good if not better than most footballers in Europe's top divisions where passing acumen is in question.

Ter Stegen is the best keeper in the world right now and I wouldn't have Neuer in the top three at all.

As for the young keepers... Kepa is THERE!  Donnarumma has talent and shown it but Kepa has been performing and he's only going to get better with time.  So much so that already in Spain there's a debate as to whether or not he should take the place of David de Gea.

[RandoEFC]

De Gea is still top drawer for me. However he has been a bit poor for the last few months by his standards. I'll openly admit I've not seen enough of the others but Oblak deserves a special mention from those outside the Premier League.

[SirBalon]

Just now, RandoEFC said:

De Gea is still top drawer for me. However he has been a bit poor for the last few months by his standards. I'll openly admit I've not seen enough of the others but Oblak deserves a special mention from those outside the Premier League.

For me right NOW it's between Ter Stegen and Oblak as the best keepers.

I thought @BartraPique1932 Would've been more vocal about this and I'm awaiting our own keeper specialist in the shape of @Fusion to give us his opinion.

[RandoEFC]

Just now, SirBalon said:

For me right NOW it's between Ter Stegen and Oblak as the best keepers.

I thought @BartraPique1932 Would've been more vocal about this and I'm awaiting our own keeper specialist in the shape of @Fusion to give us his opinion.

I haven't seen Ter Stegen rely on his feet to make saves so he has that over De Gea at least.

[SirBalon]

Just now, RandoEFC said:

I haven't seen Ter Stegen rely on his feet to make saves so he has that over De Gea at least.

Have a look at the highlights from yesterday's game between Barça and Sevilla.  In that game you'll see an example of how he uses every part of his body with incredible first save recovery to keep out point blank situations.

[RandoEFC]

1 minute ago, SirBalon said:

Have a look at the highlights from yesterday's game between Barça and Sevilla.  In that game you'll see an example of how he uses every part of his body with incredible first save recovery to keep out point blank situations.

If he makes saves with his feet, he is a fraud.

[SirBalon]

2 minutes ago, RandoEFC said:

If he makes saves with his feet, he is a fraud.

Hahaha

Just found this from last night's game although there were more saves (ignore the music )

 

[God is Haaland]

2 minutes ago, RandoEFC said:

Watch the highlights and bow down, you muppet.

[God is Haaland]

9 minutes ago, SirBalon said:

For me right NOW it's between Ter Stegen and Oblak as the best keepers.

I thought @BartraPique1932 Would've been more vocal about this and I'm awaiting our own keeper specialist in the shape of @Fusion to give us his opinion.

That'll show him. Got your back, mate.

[SirBalon]

Just now, BartraPique1932 said:

That'll show him. Got your back, mate.

He said he hasn't watched the games mate so under that scenario he can't really comment adecuately. That's why I've brought up Ter Stegen's highlights. 

[RandoEFC]

2 minutes ago, BartraPique1932 said:

Watch the highlights and bow down, you muppet.

What authority do you have to question the gospel of 20Legend? On your bike son.

[God is Haaland]

Just now, SirBalon said:

He said he hasn't watched the games mate so under that scenario he can't really comment adecuately. That's why I've brought up Ter Stegen's highlights. 

And you're 100% right. "That'll show him" refers to my own post.

[God is Haaland]

Ter Stegen surpasses Neuer and probably all other goal keepers in all category but one.

Neuer does probably still have the better timing when he leaves his own box in order intercept, but MATS is better on the line, is able to jump more explosively and got an even better distribution with his feet.

https://streamable.com/g1dz8

No other La Liga goal keeper has saved as many clear chances as MATS over the course of the last 12 months.

Edited October 21, 2018 by BartraPique1932

[Inverted]

De Gea's only world-class attribute is his shot stopping. If he's in a bit of a slump even in that, there's no way you can argue for him being best in the world imo.

[JoshBRFC]

ter Stegan is well on his way. 

People are hating on De Gea recently, but it's been hard when he's got such a shite defence in front of him.

[RandoEFC]

Pickford should be in the poll when he learns to save penalties with his hands instead of his feet.

[SirBalon]

21 minutes ago, RandoEFC said:

Pickford should be in the poll when he learns to save penalties with his hands instead of his feet.

To be honest I could’ve put Pickford in there before some of those I did  But if I didn’t put Navas in there @Blue would’ve accused me of something untoward. 

[Inverted]

4 hours ago, JOSHBRFC said:

ter Stegan is well on his way. 

People are hating on De Gea recently, but it's been hard when he's got such a shite defence in front of him.

I’d actually say that having a shite defence can flatter a goalie sometimes. There’s more opportunity to look good when your side is under pressure and getting battered for 90 mins.

Goalies are more prone to getting found out when their side is dominant, and they’re going to get judged on whether they deliver in just one or two decisive moments.

De Gea seems to thrive in the first scenario, and struggle in the second.

[Happy Blue]

 Who's the best keeper in the world, then he leaves the best keeper in the world off the list    ...it's clearly Ederson, not only does he keep the ball out the net in the top League in Europe but he also assists goals too

[AMG]

No Akinfeev, no vote 

 

Oh, and DonnaRumma is the future GOAT.

[God is Haaland]

Btw Areola > Becker, Lloris

[Storts]

1 hour ago, BartraPique1932 said:

Btw Areola > Becker, Lloris

Areola can't even get in the French team over Lloris. Silly post

[God is Haaland]

20 hours ago, RandoEFC said:

What authority do you have to question the gospel of 20Legend? On your bike son.

Who did 20Legend criticise for using his feet?

[Stan]

34 minutes ago, BartraPique1932 said:

Who did 20Legend criticise for using his feet?

De Gea

[Cicero]

De Gea hasn't been that impressive from what I've seen this 3/4 of the year. Ter Stegan has been consistent for a good while now. 

 

[Viva la FCB]

On 21/10/2018 at 07:20, SirBalon said:

Neuer is indeed class but we always have to leave a margin open for betterment, for natural talent and evolution.  Marc-André ter Stegen covers all of these categories and more.  Anyone that follows Barcelona will know what he has achieved on an individual argument and also taking into account how Barcelona play the game which has always meant that a keeper is more open to being tested.  All this without even going into his football technical ability with the ball at his feet because he is as good if not better than most footballers in Europe's top divisions where passing acumen is in question.

Ter Stegen is the best keeper in the world right now and I wouldn't have Neuer in the top three at all.

As for the young keepers... Kepa is THERE!  Donnarumma has talent and shown it but Kepa has been performing and he's only going to get better with time.  So much so that already in Spain there's a debate as to whether or not he should take the place of David de Gea.

I mean thats not much of a stretch he basically hasnt been healthy for 2 seasons now. He hasnt regained his former form, maybe he will maybe he wont. Prior to it wasnt even a close contest, Neuer hands down was the best for a stretch of a few years anyways.  

I havent had time to keep up outside of big clashes here and there and CL games so im not the best judge for this at the moment but I have to say Oblak has been impressively consistently for several years now though.

Edited October 22, 2018 by Viva la FCB

[Stan]

Ter Stegen right now.

Donnarumma for the future.