Who Is The Worst Replacement For A Departing Star You've Ever Signed?

[Steve Bruce Almighty 2,764]

 

[Stan 9,114]

Before I even opened the thread I thought of Akinbiyi for Heskey  

[Harry 1,167]

Alberto Aquilani for Xabi Alonso?

Balotelli for Suarez?

Andy Carrol for Fernando Torres?

We’ve signed some other really shitty players but not always as a clear and direct replacement for a departing star.

[LFCMike 1,499]

2 minutes ago, Harry said:

Alberto Aquilani for Xabi Alonso?

Balotelli for Suarez?

Andy Carrol for Fernando Torres?

We’ve signed some other really shitty players but not always as a clear and direct replacement for a departing star.

Add Mignolet for Reina to that list too

[Storts 1,745]

Frazier Campbell on loan for Berbatov 

 

[JOSHBRFC 467]

Steve Kean for Sam Allardyce. 

[Devil-Dick Willie 1,452]

Shiiiiiiiit. There's a few

 

Denni Avdic for Hugo Almeida

Wesley for Ozil

Wolfe for Mertesacker 

 

[nudge 7,626]

13 minutes ago, Devil-Dick Willie said:

Shiiiiiiiit. There's a few

 

Denni Avdic for Hugo Almeida

Wesley for Ozil

Wolfe for Mertesacker 

 

Carlos Alberto for Klose.

Haha.

[Dan 1,304]

Rachid Ghezzal for Riyad Mahrez. I want to think Maddison was the actual replacement though.

[Tommy 4,496]

1 hour ago, nudge said:

Carlos Alberto for Klose.

Haha.

Haha, I remember that farce. 

[RandoEFC 4,288]

Replacing Lukaku with literally nobody wasn't our best move.

It's hard to isolate too many direct replacements when you haven't had that many star players in recent memory. God we're shit.

[Vegan Kel 171]

Berbatov for Saha, Liam Miller (RIP) for Roy Keane, Laurent Blanc for Stam. Could probably go on and on here

[Dr. Gonzo 4,191]

On ‎05‎/‎01‎/‎2019 at 02:48, LFCMike said:

Add Mignolet for Reina to that list too

Poulsen for Mascherano

[Harry 1,167]

16 hours ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

Poulsen for Mascherano

I thought about Poulsen. But I thought the logic at the time was that Lucas was effectively the replacement for masch.

[SirBalon 69 855]

Giroud for Van Persie

Eduardo for Henry.

[LFCMike 1,499]

2 hours ago, Harry said:

I thought about Poulsen. But I thought the logic at the time was that Lucas was effectively the replacement for masch.

I think Poulsen was signed earlier in the summer although I think he probably was the Mascherano replacement because Liverpool knew he was going that window. We also signed Meireles around the time Mascherano went. Two different types of midfielders though obviously.

[Dr. Gonzo 4,191]

2 hours ago, LFCMike said:

I think Poulsen was signed earlier in the summer although I think he probably was the Mascherano replacement because Liverpool knew he was going that window. We also signed Meireles around the time Mascherano went. Two different types of midfielders though obviously.

Meireles was way better out wide for us than he ever was as a central midfielder.

[LFCMike 1,499]

20 minutes ago, Dr. Gonzo said:

Meireles was way better out wide for us than he ever was as a central midfielder.

Yeah I remember him being decent there after Dalglish came in.

[MUFC 359]

Fucking Valencia for Ronaldo.

[Faithcore 1,001]

Erik Bo Andersen , "The Red Romario" from Denmark, for Bachirou Salou.